Embers and Ashes
In the backcountry, you sometimes stumble upon the remains of an old camp. Blackened stones sag in a broken ring. Ash lies scattered by the wind. No heat or smoke. No hum of voices.
It’s a still life of absence. You can almost hear the missing pieces. The hiss of wood catching flame, the low murmur between friends, the shared stories that knit the night together.
That’s where many men’s circles stand today. The fire went out.
And with it, a vital source of warmth for the heart.
We can’t just talk about starting the fire again. We have to rebuild it. With science, soul, and a workable map. Without both the research and the ritual, we’ll keep striking matches in the wind. As I shared in Crock Pot Faith, lasting transformation rarely comes from quick sparks. It grows through steady tending, like a fire that’s built to burn through the night
Why the Fire Matters (and What the Science Says)
Healthy male friendships are not a luxury. They are a public-health necessity.
In 2023, the U.S. Surgeon General issued a stark advisory: social disconnection increases the risk of depression, anxiety, heart disease, stroke, dementia, and premature death at rates comparable to smoking up to 15 cigarettes a day (Office of the Surgeon General, 2023). In other words, the absence of a campfire is not just cold, it’s deadly.
Decades of findings: people with close friends report higher life satisfaction and lower depression than those without such connections (APA, 2023). These friendships aren’t an emotional “extra.” They shape long-term mental and physical health outcomes.
From a neuroscience perspective, Daniel Siegel’s (2023) interpersonal neurobiology framework explains why. At the core of well-being is integration: linking differentiated parts: thought and feeling, body and mind, “me” and “we.” Real friendship is one of the most effective “neural gyms” for integration, because it trains attunement (tuning into each other’s signals), resonance (feeling with, not just for), and repair (restoring connection after rupture).
For men specifically, research on alternative male friendship models finds that intentionally cultivated men’s groups (especially those practicing vulnerability, mutual support, and non-competitive affirmation) measurably improve emotional well-being and downstream physical health (Ríos-González et al., 2021).
When the fire burns, it changes us.
When it goes out, we notice. Sometimes too late.
Why the Fire Went Out – Cultural & Relational Erosion
Men’s circles didn’t go cold for just one reason. They cooled because of overlapping forces:
- Lost Rites of Passage
For centuries, boys became men through embodied initiation—rituals witnessed by community, grounded in responsibility. Without these rites, boys improvise their own: forming digital “squads,” chasing hustle culture, or seeking adrenaline in risk-taking. These are high on intensity, low on formation. - Busyness & Fragmentation
We live with less margin, more screens, and fewer lingering conversations. Friendships slip into “as-needed” status instead of living in our daily or weekly rhythm. Without consistent tending, even strong connections go out. - Suspicion of Male-Only Spaces
In an age rightly attentive to safety and equity, all-male spaces sometimes draw suspicion. The answer isn’t to abandon them, but to build them with structure, transparency, and integrity. - The Narrow Ridge Double-Bind
As I explored in The Narrow Ridge, men often hear that tenderness equals weakness and anger is “allowed” but tightly policed. Too much and you’re dangerous; too little and you’re apathetic. Many men retreat into silence. - Shame & Secrecy
Brené Brown (2012) says shame thrives in secrecy and isolation—and dissolves in empathy and truth. Without campfire spaces, shame goes unchallenged, leaving men alone with the heaviest parts of their stories.
These forces don’t just dim the flame; they dismantle the fire ring.
How to Rebuild the Campfire
Every step here aligns with what we know about human connection, emotional safety, and habit formation.
1. Tinder – Start Small, Make It Rhythmic
Tinder catches first. It’s small, light, and easy to ignite. In friendship, start with low-barrier, repeatable contact:
- Weekly coffee
- Monthly hike
- Standing Thursday night call
The Surgeon General’s advisory underscores the health value of consistent, high-quality interactions. Rhythmic contact tells the nervous system, I can count on this.
2. Logs – Design for Challenge and Co-Regulation
Logs are the long-burn fuel. In friendship, shared challenges build deep bonds—trail work, cold-morning runs, training for a climb. Co-regulation happens here: steadying each other’s nervous systems through presence in difficulty.
3. Flame Guard – Rules That Protect the Fire
Every fire needs a guard from the wind. Friendships need rules that protect the connection:
- Keep confidentiality
- Don’t fix without permission
- Choose curiosity over critique
- Share from the “I,” assume positive intent, value repair over perfection
These align with Brown’s shame-resilience framework: empathy, courage, grounded boundaries.
4. Kindling Skills – Practice Connection, Don’t Just Talk About It
Kindling keeps the fire going between logs. Practice micro-skills that deepen connection:
- Name and Notice: one minute of body check-in
- Reflect Back: mirror content and feeling
- Repair Reps: use short, practiced scripts for friction moments
5. Passing the Torch – Intergenerational Mentorship
Strong fires pass heat forward. In healthy male culture, older and younger men share life and work side-by-side. Studies show that non-competitive affirmation and mutual uplift increase group cohesion and health outcomes (Ríos-González et al., 2021). Thin Air & Turning Points shows how the steady presence of a guide (someone who walks beside you, not ahead) can change the trajectory of a man’s life
6. Banking the Coals – Protect the Flame Long-Term
At night, you bank coals to keep the fire alive. In male friendships, that means rotating leadership, holding clear boundaries, and favoring celebration over comparison.
Where Women Fit In
Women often carry a heavy share of emotional labor, serving as a man’s sole confidant, sounding board, and crisis responder. Robust male friendships lighten this load.
As The Times recently noted in its coverage of “mankeeping,” expecting one partner to be a man’s best friend, therapist, and personal assistant is unsustainable. Men with strong peer networks, have families that thrive. Rather than settling on one person, stress spreads. Conversations deepen. Emotional resilience rises.
Women can help. Not by managing men’s friendships, but by affirming their value and encouraging space for them. What the River Knows explores this mutual respect.
From Cold Stones to Warm Flames
A cold fire ring only tells you a fire once burned. However, it says nothing about whether one can burn again.
Rebuilding takes effort:
- Someone gathers tinder.
- Someone shields the spark.
- Someone tends the coals.
Start with two men and a rhythm you can keep. Add challenge, safety, and honest stories. Protect the flame with care and skill. Over time, you’ll notice more warmth, less isolation, and a steadier mind and heart.
Brené Brown calls vulnerability “the birthplace of love, belonging, joy, courage, empathy, and creativity.” That’s the heat we’re after.
Daniel Siegel reminds us that integration (me and we) is the architecture of a healthy mind. Build that, and the next generation won’t inherit a cold ring of stones. They’ll inherit a fire.
You might also like
